|
|
Violence
and Growth in Colombia: A Brief Review of the Literature
By:
Alvaro J. Riascos and Juan F. Vargas
Introduction
This is a brief review of the specialized economic
literature on the consequences on growth of criminality
and conflict in Colombia. It has been guided by
at least three points. First we focus on economic
growth. That is, we leave aside studies that have
had as their variable of interest the level of
output. Second we do not distinguish among works
using conflict or criminality variables, nor we
differentiate between forms of criminality or
ask about their origins. The majority of the papers
we refer to, focus on criminality figures. Still,
some of them also use data on the internal conflict.
These are two different phenomena although there
is a strong relationship between them. When presenting
the literature we will stick to the concepts used
in the corresponding paper by the different authors,
otherwise -in the rest of this introduction as
well as the conclusions- we will use the word
'violence' to refer to both criminality and conflict.
As for criminality, it is sometimes associated
with the homicide rate, manslaughter, street crime,
crime against property, drug trafficking, kidnapping
or a mixture of some or all of these actions.
Again, we will use 'violence' although we believe
that a clear distinction of the different activities
and their impact on the economic growth should
be at the top of any research agenda on the topic.
The third and foremost is that we focus on quantitative
studies that using diverse methodologies have
tried to identify the effects of violence.
In a sense, rather than just writing a survey,
we contribute to the literature by making a constructive
critique of the different methodologies. We conclude
with a short summary of what we have learned from
these studies and point out to what we think should
be the focus of future research on the subject.
Additional to the referred studies, at the end
we also offer a long list of references on criminality
and conflict which not necessarily fit to our
three criteria but that can be of some use for
those who want to learn about the Colombian literature
on this topic.
Finally, we apologize for not having been exhaustive
in the review. We recognize that there might be
a few influential studies missing. However, our
objective has been to review a few but nevertheless
important studies and to start documenting the
state of knowledge of what we think is an important
research for Colombian economists and other social
scientists. In any case, it is for them to help
us complete this survey and contribute in constructing
a quantitative view of the relation between growth
and violence in Colombia based on the existing
studies that meet the three previously mentioned
guidelines. Therefore, all comments and suggestions
are welcome to enhance this review.
Descargar documento completo
(archivo
pdf 275kb)
|
|